Exploring Sarasota's Top 10 Neighborhoods in 2024: A Comprehensive Guide

As we approach the end of 2023, it's the perfect time to delve into the exciting prospects of Sarasota's real estate in 2024. Sarasota, Florida, known for its stunning beaches, vibrant culture, and thriving community, offers a diverse array of neighborhoods that cater to various lifestyles and preferences.

In this article (derived from my full length YouTube Video), we'll explore 10 of my favorite neighborhoods in Sarasota for 2024, covering both new and resale properties, 55+ communities, and areas offering exceptional value.

Whether you're planning to relocate or invest in Sarasota's dynamic real estate market, this guide will provide valuable insights into each neighborhood's unique charm and potential.

(1) Brightmore at Wellen Park: A New Benchmark in 55+ Living (New Construction)

Kicking off our list is Brightmore, a new construction gem by Mattamy Homes in Wellen Park. This 55+ community is a standout in South Venice/Western Northport for its unique offerings in an area where new, age-targeted developments are scarce.

Brightmore promises rapid sales due to its well-thought-out amenities, strategic location, and surprising affordability. The community not only offers standard amenities but also introduces resort-style pools, clubhouse facilities, and a unique campus-like atmosphere, making it an excellent choice for active seniors.

(2) Lakehouse Cove: A Resale/New Community with Diverse Appeal (Resale)

For mostly resale options, Lakehouse Cove in the Waterside district could be a top pick. Master developed by Homes by Towne, this community offers an elegant, high-end living experience with both templated builds and custom construction options.

In addition to Homes by Towne, it features residences by renowned builders like Arthur Rutenberg, Lee Wetherington, and John Cannon, providing a variety of luxurious options.

The community's amenities, including a gym overlooking the lake and a boathouse for paddleboards and kayaks, make it a standout choice for those seeking a blend of luxury and comfort.

(3) Shellstone at Waterside: Homes by Towne's Newest Venture (New Construction)

Continuing with the new construction offerings, Shellstone, another Homes by Towne creation in Waterside, will offer an intriguing mix of upscale living and strategic location.

This community is set to feature newer models and potentially upgraded amenities, starting at around the $1MM mark. Its location, adjacent to large water & Wild Blue positions Shellstone as a top contender for those seeking sophisticated living in Lakewood Ranch more into 2024.

(4) Misty Creek: The Essence of Old School Sarasota Charm (Resale)

On the resale front, Misty Creek represents the quintessence of old-school Sarasota.

Nestled below Artistry and above Grand Park, this community offers central accessibility to key areas like downtown Sarasota, Siesta Key, Waterside, Fruitville Commons, etc.; while retaining its unique charm.

Misty Creek's appeal lies in its larger lot sizes, lower HOA fees, and the classic Florida home aesthetic, making it an attractive option for those yearning for a slice of Sarasota's historic allure.

(5) Vistera Of Venice: A New Masterplan with Diverse Builder Options (New Construction)

The new Vistera community in North Venice is a masterplan concept offering a choice between builders like MI Homes, David Weekly, and Neal Communities. It combines affordability, variety in home styles, and typical amenities like resort-style pools and fitness centers.

The community's location, parallel to Nokomis, bridges the gap between Lakewood Ranch and Wellen Park, offering an excellent opportunity for those seeking a blend of convenience and community.

(6) Lakewood Ranch Golf and Country Club: A Fusion of Old and New (Resale)

Lakewood Ranch Golf and Country Club is a unique blend of Lakewood Ranch's original charm and modern development. This community, mostly established in the late-90s/early 2000's, offers a mix of mature landscapes and contemporary amenities.

It's known for its 3 golf courses, 2 clubhouses, and a variety of membership options, making it an attractive destination for golf enthusiasts and those seeking a blend of old and new Sarasota.

(7) Everly at Wellen Park: Redefining Luxury in South Venice (New Construction)

Everly, located in Wellen Park, stands out for its luxurious offerings in a region that traditionally lacked such options. This new community is noted for its custom home builders, large lots, and exclusive amenities, including access to pickleball and a chip and putt facility.

Everly is perfect for those seeking a luxurious lifestyle in a coastal, walkable area with proximity to beaches.

(8) The Lakes: A Unique Old School Sarasota Community (Resale)

The Lakes offers another old-school Sarasota experience with its central location and sprawling single-family homes. This community, parallel to Lido Key, features villas and single-family homes on larger lots, providing a serene yet conveniently located living experience.

It’s ideal for those who prefer a more traditional Sarasota neighborhood with central proximity.

(9) Esplanade at Azario: Northeast Lakewood Ranch’s Crown Jewel (New Construction)

Esplanade at Azario in Northeast Lakewood Ranch is known for its exceptional amenities and beautiful community layout. This community offers elegantly designed homes and is particularly appealing for its golf course, multiple pools, and pickleball courts.

It's a great choice for those who value new construction with a range of amenities and scenic views.

(10) Cherokee Park: The Quintessence of Sarasota’s Historic Charm (Resale)

Cherokee Park, encapsulating Sarasota's historic value, is known for its large non-HOA lots and proximity to key Sarasota landmarks like Lido Beach, Siesta Key, & downtown Sarasota.

This neighborhood is ideal for those seeking a blend of urban convenience and old-world charm, with its beautiful homes and easy access to shopping, beaches, and downtown Sarasota.

---

In conclusion, Sarasota's real estate scene in 2024 presents a rich tapestry of communities, each with its unique charm and offerings. From the golf-centric Lakewood Ranch Golf and Country Club to the luxurious Everly in Wellen Park, and the historic allure of Cherokee Park, there is a neighborhood to match every lifestyle and preference.

Whether you're a golfer, a beach lover, or someone who cherishes the old-world charm, Sarasota's top neighborhoods in 2024 provide an array of choices for discerning homebuyers.